Where Is the Enemy?
Some governments, when confronted with public questions, choose to create enemies rather than provide answers. It is an easy way to escape responsibility, because accountability means acknowledging mistakes, explaining performance, and enduring criticism. But when every problem can be blamed on an “enemy,” there is no need to discuss the roots of those problems. Costs, corruption, and incompetence become the result of conspiracies. Public dissatisfaction is turned into foreign provocation. Critics become foreign agents, and political rivals become threats to national security.
The problem begins when this narrative moves from foreign policy into domestic politics, where the government portrays opponents as enemies rather than competitors.
Turkey today is a clear example of this.
For years, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has pursued his politics through a combination of nationalism, security, and warnings about internal and external threats. Of course, Turkey has faced genuine security threats, from armed groups to the wars surrounding its borders. Therefore, it would be wrong to claim that all threats are fabricated.
But the problem becomes serious when “security threats” are used as a tool against a political rival. Selahattin Demirtaş is a clear example. A prominent political figure and former leader of the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP), he received nearly 10 percent of the vote in the 2014 presidential election and was arrested in 2016. He has remained in prison for years. The European Court of Human Rights has also ruled against Turkey in various cases concerning his detention and called for his release.
Demirtaş was not merely a political activist; he was a rival who won millions of votes and challenged Erdoğan from within the same political system.
Later, a similar pattern emerged in a different form with Ekrem İmamoğlu. The mayor, who defeated Erdoğan and his party in the Istanbul elections, has become one of his most serious political rivals. İmamoğlu’s trial and detention have also triggered widespread debate over judicial independence and the political use of legal proceedings in Turkey.
The Turkish government rejects these accusations and insists that the judiciary is independent. But critics argue that when an electoral rival ends up in court and prison instead of simply competing at the ballot box, the issue can no longer be dismissed as an ordinary political dispute.
Here, a simple question must be asked:
If a political rival is an enemy, then what is the purpose of elections?
But this contradiction is not limited to domestic politics.
Erdoğan has also repeatedly spoken of foreign threats in his foreign policy. The United States, Europe, Israel, various regional groups, and foreign powers have occupied different positions in Ankara’s political narrative depending on circumstances.
But here an interesting contradiction emerges.
Turkey disagrees with the United States on many issues, yet it is a member of NATO and continues to negotiate with Washington.
Turkey competes with Russia on many regional issues, yet it also maintains extensive economic and political relations with Moscow.
Turkey has serious political disagreements with Europe, yet Europe remains one of Turkey’s most important economic partners.
And Israel may be the most interesting example.
Turkey was the first Muslim-majority country to recognize Israel, in 1949. Relations between the two countries were, at times, very close, and extensive economic and military cooperation developed between them. Today, however, Erdoğan presents himself as one of Israel’s strongest critics.
Naturally, the foreign policies of countries change. Countries have no permanent friends or permanent enemies, and national interests can reshape relationships.
But the problem arises when a country is declared an enemy today and sits at the negotiating table tomorrow. We then have to ask what exactly “hostility” means.
Perhaps the answer lies in the famous principle of international politics: countries have no permanent friends or permanent enemies; they have permanent interests.
But when the same logic is applied to domestic politics, the situation becomes dangerous.
Because if a political rival can be called an enemy, if a protest can be called a conspiracy, and if a critic can be declared a foreign agent, the government no longer has to compete with its opponent; it only has to transform that opponent from a “rival” into a “threat.”
At that point, the issue is no longer merely politics; it is about power.
There is no doubt that Erdoğan is a skilled player when it comes to power. He knows how to create a narrative, how to turn a security concern into a political crisis, and how to shift public attention from one question to another.
But people have memories too. And the question remains:
If America is the enemy, why do we negotiate with it?
If Russia is the enemy, why do we cooperate with it?
If Israel is the enemy, what happens to the economic relations between the two countries?
And if Demirtaş and İmamoğlu are threats to Turkey, why not let the Turkish people decide their fate at the ballot box?
Perhaps the real enemy is not always on the other side of the border.
Sometimes the greatest problem a government faces is the very question it refuses to answer.
And if a new enemy is created every day to avoid accountability, one question remains:
Why are the friends behind the scenes, while the enemies are on the stage?
Author: Gouya Roshan
All Rights Reserved.

Comments
Post a Comment